- Joined
- Dec 25, 2011
- Messages
- 10,552
thenrie,
In my opinion, a BXA is too large for a 12". So it would follow that it would be too large for an 11". I know of a guy in Australia who came across a good deal up here (in the USA) on a BXA and bought it for his Atlas 10". His comment after receiving it was that the extremely high cost of shipping made it financially impractical to return the BXA, so he was going to have to make do. But that he really wished he had bought an AXA. I know two or three people with Atlas 12" who bought BXA and claim that it works. But I always suspected that they would have been happier with AXA and just didn't want to say so.
I have an AXA on my 12" Atlas 3996 (sometimes called the "Commercial). You can now buy oversize 101 and 102 tool holders for the AXA toolpost if you have need to hold 5/8" tooling. The standard holders will hold up to 1/2" although they were nominally designed for 3/8", which is mostly what I use.
Robert D.
In my opinion, a BXA is too large for a 12". So it would follow that it would be too large for an 11". I know of a guy in Australia who came across a good deal up here (in the USA) on a BXA and bought it for his Atlas 10". His comment after receiving it was that the extremely high cost of shipping made it financially impractical to return the BXA, so he was going to have to make do. But that he really wished he had bought an AXA. I know two or three people with Atlas 12" who bought BXA and claim that it works. But I always suspected that they would have been happier with AXA and just didn't want to say so.
I have an AXA on my 12" Atlas 3996 (sometimes called the "Commercial). You can now buy oversize 101 and 102 tool holders for the AXA toolpost if you have need to hold 5/8" tooling. The standard holders will hold up to 1/2" although they were nominally designed for 3/8", which is mostly what I use.
Robert D.