You know, I used actually think this very same way. But now as I get older, I realize that some of my back ups or spares (not just tool related) may never get used in the years I have left. Although I'm not really old yet I can still see that some of it may never get the chance to be used by me. So now I think the opposite, I'll use the best of what I have first when needed.
Problem I have & I know I'm not alone (hopefully) is I buy back ups for backups for certain things I know or feel won't be available or easy to get later on if/when I need another. It's a disease or I'm just mentally ill.
But I get it & can relate, for example, I have 2 sets of gauge blocks. One is generic Chinese import, the other is Mitutoyo. I'll use the generic primarily & only the Mitu for fussy stuff (which is rare for me). But really not sure why I even have this reasoning as I don't have a need to use gauge blocks often anyway.