Best VFD”s on the market

I like "KB" brand VFDs, have five of 'em. USA-made, high quality, not the cheapest but I'm happy with the value. I've gotten most of mine from ebay as "New - open box" or used, no problems to report. If you're a business, you probably shouldn't risk the used route, but I'm a hobbyist, downtime is not a problem. Which hasn't happened, but I probably have less safety margin than with always buying new.

When you're not in a hurry to buy one, you can wait for the right price. I had a Saved Search in ebay for the model I wanted, with a maximum price so they don't email me with every full-price one that comes along. My most recent one was Open Box and I could tell it had never been used. Luckily for me no one else bid, and I got it for the opening bid, about half the normal "street price".

I especially like the KBs with a "wash down" totally sealed enclosure. Not all their models have that feature; the ones that do cost a bit more. But it means I don't need to build it into an electrical box and worry about cooling fans (or overheating). That wouldn't be a priority for you if you're putting it in an electrical box anyway.

After the first one, I stayed with KB 'cuz now it's a known quantity. I learned how to program them and I'm lazy, don't want to learn another brand. Though I admit programming a VFD is pretty easy, and they're all kinda similar. I do hear reports about difficult to understand manuals with cheap Asian units though. It's easy to read a KB manual, and if you need support, they speak English.

If you're buying multiple drives, there's benefits to having them be similar or same if possible. Like you might be able to cannibalize one machine to keep another one running if one drive goes bad. A biz that can't handle downtime could keep one extra drive as a spare, so long as it'll work on all the machines.

On my belt grinder, I programmed the VFD to display in surface feet per minute at the belt, rather than RPM or frequency (Hz) which is the default. It doesn't really make much of difference, but I thought it was cool that it let me do that. (I am easily amused.)
 
Hello Ladies and gentlemen , as some of you already know I recently purchased a few 3 phase surface grinders and being without 3 phase power leaves me in need of a few VFD to fit the bill and get these things up and running. That’s what leads me to this question. Which variable frequency drives should I be looking at, not just spec wise but primarily which brands and models are out there in today’s market that won’t break the bank and will do a great job? Just want to hear what you guys are using and what you like or dislike about them. Looking forward to hearing all your experiences and comments. Thanks for participating
Just remember, You don't just hook the cord to the vfd and go about your day. You have to wire directly to the motor and eliminate magnetic contactors and such from the original control panel. The VFD has inputs for switches and other controls though. It's not plug and play as a Rotary Phase Converter is.
 
Best needs probably some further explanation whether you are looking at quality, price or advanced features. I worked many years for Siemens and their drives are certainly high quality and feature rich (but a pain to program for non-experts). I am running a Hitachi WJ200 on my lathe and it is a reasonable compromise between quality power electronics, good features, relatively easy programming and price. I refurbished a 3 phase compressor and used a generic Chinese VFD (Mollom) that works just fine for running a 3ph motor at constant speed and was pretty much best price.

As other people have pointed out, VFDs are best of you only have a single motor to run. If you have several 3 phase machines and think you may acquire more, i would look into a digital phase converter like phase perfect. They are more expensive than a rotary phase converter but more capable of handling varying loads than an RPC.

So depending on the surface grinder, i.e. if you just have to power a relatively low hp spindle, I would just give a single cheap Chinese VFD a go. Running a 3ph motor at more or less constant speed is not the most demanding of applications.
 
Best needs probably some further explanation whether you are looking at quality, price or advanced features. I worked many years for Siemens and their drives are certainly high quality and feature rich (but a pain to program for non-experts). I am running a Hitachi WJ200 on my lathe and it is a reasonable compromise between quality power electronics, good features, relatively easy programming and price. I refurbished a 3 phase compressor and used a generic Chinese VFD (Mollom) that works just fine for running a 3ph motor at constant speed and was pretty much best price.

As other people have pointed out, VFDs are best of you only have a single motor to run. If you have several 3 phase machines and think you may acquire more, i would look into a digital phase converter like phase perfect. They are more expensive than a rotary phase converter but more capable of handling varying loads than an RPC.

So depending on the surface grinder, i.e. if you just have to power a relatively low hp spindle, I would just give a single cheap Chinese VFD a go. Running a 3ph motor at more or less constant speed is not the most demanding of applications.

I like "KB" brand VFDs, have five of 'em. USA-made, high quality, not the cheapest but I'm happy with the value.
+1 for KB VFD's as I have 3 of the below and really like them as no need for buying and enclosure, control switches, etc.
KBMA-24D Black (9533) AC Drives, Nema 1 Inverter 1 HP, 115/230 Vac 1-Phase Input, 230 Vac 3-Phase Output, Nema 1(IP50) Enclosure, Variable Frequency Drives
Harry
 
Thank you to everyone participating. I only have experience with one VFD and it’s an older teco. I love it. I have had no trouble at all out of it. I do have it in an enclosure with a fan and it’s controllled by a pendant I made
 
Pretty much covered here. Just one more vote for the Hitachi WJ200. GREAT MANUAL, easiest to program. good quality and fair price, especially if you shop a bit. I have eight in use.

Tried a Teco, had trouble with programming but it works great.

Tried a Chinese no name. The wiring terminals were too small and it burned out.
 
I’ve had a great experience setting up an Automation Direct (my first experience with a VFD) and a very difficult time with a Chinese ENC.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top