What type should I order?
Yeah, it can be confusing.
This is my 3rd edit, because I *used* to buy
just the stones I needed, but Geisswein has changed how they do business..... You see I only order from them ever 10 or so years, and just to add to my collection, because I haven't worn out any of their stones... yet! Nowadays you have to order a set or a box of stones. No individual stones any more.
I'm afraid you will have to order a basic set of die stones, instead of just getting the 2 stones I intended, that would have been 1" wide. This set has is the 405-2063. It is only 1/2" wide, so you will have to take care to move back and forth evenly. You would use the 400 grit and up. You don't use a lot of pressure for an operation like this and plenty of flushing lube (stoning oil, WD-40, or my favourite, low-odour Varsol) The set should be less than 50 bucks.
It is a touch expensive (because of the way they package their stones now), but I'd buy a box of 12 soft finishing stones, 440-9003. These are 1200 grit, but the way they break down and their softness leaves a much better finish. They get used up much quicker than die stones. This will leave a satin finish free from any scratches from the die stones. A box of 12 is around 60 bucks.
As an alternative, you can use the 3m lapping films in the 2000 and 4000 grit (10 and 5 micron) which should give you a decent finish with good contact. The lapping film should be cheaper, depending on how it is packaged. I don't know the pricing because I've just experimented with lapping film. I usually stone and then lap using diamond paste. I wouldn't recommend this approach for a first-timer.
Here's a link to a chart of all the Geisswein stones, and what each stone is made for:
*** I have no affiliation with Geisswein - I've used their stones for over 40 years, and they are what I am familiar with. ***