Remember Junkyard Wars, not super popular, but I sure liked it.
Yep I liked that one too, in both of it's varieties; Scrap-Heap Challenge(British), Junkyard Wars(US). I still have some on VHS.
Problem with the show was: The hosts were not 'shop types'... which IMO kinda destroyed the potential for the show. The competition at the end was the fun part!
I liked the hosts I saw. They seemed to ask the questions that most non-techies would. I thought that brought it "closer to the people" and hoped it would extend its longevity.
The Car and Bike build shows seem to top of list.
My problem with most of the bike and car build shows is that they focus way too much on attitudes and disagreements.
They spend 40 minutes of the hour *****ing, 10 minutes in commercials and only 10 minutes doing anything like actually welding, building, etc.
Apparently, that's what most viewers like.
In my book that makes them "soap operas"......and I don't care to watch that BS.
Forged in Fire, in spite of it's minor faults, still seems to show mostly people working metal.
I guess they feel they have to include some danger/stupidity and "drama" (as
@GA Gyro says) to sell it to the masses.
My two cents........
-brino