You did get a good deal on that chuck. I purchased a new chuck and back plate from Shars last year. The back plate was about $45 or so. Yes, it hurt to pay that much for it, but it was sweet. I bored the register for my spindle, then the OD and registration spigot for the chuck and bolted her together. Came out at .0015 for runout, better than I could have hoped for. Long story short, it was worth every penny I paid.
I just looked up class 40 gray cast iron on Speedy Metals. 6" diameter will cost you $15.37 per inch plus shipping. Buying a rough or partially machined back plate is starting to look rather affordable in my opinion.