All AXA/250-1xx tool holders will work with either style. I've gone to several vendors (Shars, Enco, CDCO) for AXA size over more than 10 years, and have only had one tool holder that was problematical - gap too narrow, so it wouldn't go over the dovetails of my piston-type holder. It would probably have been OK with a wedge type.
Living in denial...I had the same problem with two of them. They were close though so it was easily fixed with a little hand filing.
I prefer buying the tool holders from Shars because they say "Shars" instead of "China". I know it doesn't really make any difference but at least I don't have "China" right in my face on the tool post.