I was writing as you posted your pictures of the gib. Great shots. I see the dig mark from the lock screw tip. Your gibs look a lot nicer than mine did when I took them out. clean them up and put them on your table and you can check the flatness in both directions. If it is high in the center it will spin on one point. I suggest you also take some measurements of the gib while you have it out. For the future reference. Length, thickness at several points along the length, Width, (corner to corner) along the width. I did this every inch and put it in a spread sheet to see if it varied. Some day I will make new gibs. By doing these measurements and if you find them to be straight line plots (thickness vs length etc) as they should be.... it will be useful. In theory if you know the tapper angle of the thickness along the length and the width at one point you can figure most of every thing else out.
My understanding is that they make a gib to fit, but make it extra long. They then slide it in and to finalize the fit of the gib and they cut it off when it is tight in the saddle.
Take some pictures of the scrapping. After you put it back and run it up and down a bunch you can take it out again and look at the scrapping pattern again. If it has worn off in some spots you will know where it is rubbing the most etc. Or you can just blue the scrapping marks and put it in and run the saddle up and down a couple of times and then look at the blueing. If you don't smear it off.