G'day Mark, now Friday in Oz.Hi I'm back, it's Thursday. I'm editing post #15 to be the final word on the switch hookup.
So, have you been able to confirm the two switches are identical? If you have a new one we should use that one- they wear fast
I'm going to use your test results from post #17 check above for the new data
The old switch is in pieces. What I can confirm is the switch configuration & physical dimensions are identical, and they both have 8 terminals.
I do have a new switch. It's the one in the continuity schematic below. I can confirm the continuity in the three operating positions.