Yes you are correct. The original was plastic. When the bearing seized the belt cut a groove in it. I should have mentioned the plastic. Yor project of the day beats the heck out of mine.At first blush I couldn't figure out what I was looking at in the picture showing the original idler. I imagined the original was cast iron and I wondered how aluminum was going to hold up.
I think I've figured it out now. The original is plastic and the first picture shows the groove worn through after the bearing froze. Is that correct?
My project for the day was helping you tell your story.