All too often, I have heard my friends (who worked at those oil-change-and-brake-service places for a bit) tell me, "we look at the minimum thickness on the brake rotor, then hog it off to near that. Doing it on-car results in a beautiful smooth braking experience, at the cost of needing new rotors next pad change. Doing it off-car results in a small amount of pulsing (usually not noticed by the masses), and new rotors at the next pad change. They simply hog it off, because it's there, and the tools cut better on a heavier cut.
Myself, I'd rather mic the rotors and replace if necessary. I'm too old and done *FAR* too many brake jobs to fight with wonky rotors. And I'm only 38. I'm happy to check the replacements, and send them right the heck back if necessary, but I'd rather ride a day or two on a pulsing rotor than screw with it when anything I take off brings it within .002 of the recommended thickness.
Caveat - My ex-wife and I had a Mini Cooper with Ceramic pads. 48K miles, never had to change the brakes, but when we got rid of it, the rotors were absolutely *eaten* up. Aftermarket ceramics for $200 for all 4 corners, vs $800 for all new rotors, I'd rather skip the ceramics. I only used them about *twice* to their limits in 'normal' driving, otherwise they just squalled something god-awful and did no real advantages.
Side note - With Traction Control, Stability Control, a Loud Stereo, and a Sleeping (ex)Wife in the passenger seat at 2:45am, you have to *sneak* up on a highway transfer ramp to coax a 2006 Mini Cooper into a 4-wheel-screaming drift into the merge lane. Go-Kart on steroids, tends to understeer, but if you are gentle on the wheel and throttle, it will do it. But beware of the traction snap once you start to ease it back into a straight line.
"Holy Crap, did you see that raccoon?! I had to swerve!" *whistles to self*