Update (email exchange):
Me:
"Thanks for sending another replacement. Hopefully the third time will be the charm. Do you know the tracking number for the replacement tool holder?
I will cancel the PayPal claim as soon as I get a tool holder with an adequate finish, as well as send back this one with the poor finish on the bottom.
Did you guys notice that the finish is good on all sides except for the bottom? I understand the gold lines where it may have been on a rack while it is getting blued; that is not a problem because the bare steel is protected from corrosion.
It is the scuffing and flakes that caused me to complain because, as you know, the bare steel could well lead to exposure to humidity and resultant corrosion (pitting)."
Aloris Customer Service:
"We see a claim was put through NO claim should go through Paypal per management since you are dealing direct with the factory (Aloris Tool) and this item is being sent again no charge. If any credit is to be issued this will be done directly with Aloris Tool. The bottom of our holders will never be perfect when black finished. If you would like to know the procedure you can contact our production manager. Please make sure these holds are sent back or you will be charged accordingly.
The holder will shipped via UPS no charge today 12/16/20 since UPS did not pick up at our facility yesterday."
And then they sent an image of the Picking List that includes the tracking number.
I did not open a PayPal claim until after the first replacement was received and seen to be scuffed.