Work Holding - How Not To Do It

ChazzC

H-M Supporter - Gold Member
H-M Supporter Gold Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2021
Messages
2,973
I only look at FB occasionally; this morning it was to see a video of my Grandson at the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception yesterday.

While there, I saw this horrifying post:

 
Another Hobby Machinist site ?
 
It is not our FB site which is here:

It is missing the "The" Not sure we can do anything about it.
 
Oh, because of the title I thought I was missing something related to the title.
Just a title Jeff . FWIW , I never knew we had a FB page either . Maybe they'll let me in ! :grin:
 
Sorry about that: I forgot that it's a private group (it was early and I'm old).

Here's the photo:

20241117 FB Work Holding Screw Up.png
Dude wants to take 1/4" off the OD.

I was referring to the sketchy way he has it in the chuck (plus negligible clearance to the ways). Several folks suggested a faceplate. Here is a sampling of the comments, some good, some no so:

Carry it to a real machine shop (as opposed to some random dude with a Grizzly lathe on a heavy table like me).​
Ask if you can watch (or record) from a safe distance.​
Then pay them.​

Change that Chuck
1f602.png
1f602.png
1f602.png
1f602.png
my word, we could be watching an example of the Darwinian theory of evolution before our very eyes
1f602.png
1f602.png
1f602.png
1f602.png
1f602.png
1f602.png
Seriously, this is bonkers.​
To machine that case hardened crownwheel, you need CBN even with the interrupted cut, but taking into consideration of your setup, I doubt you’ve ever heard of CBN​

I cut gears for 28yr. Anything from the space shuttle to Milwaukee hand tool. The guys are right, their going to be case harden approximately .030 -.040 case roughly 36rc on c scale and higher. Plus core hardness. It's going to be an interrupted cut on the gear teeth,this will beat the hell out of the turning tool (carbide insert) the tool post will take a beating also. Not to mention by shorting the gear teeth you'll be adding more stress to the heel of the gear tooth it self by removing the case hardness. The bearing load contact on the tooth under will put more stress at the heel.​
Bearing contact under heavy load should be full length on tooth. By shorting the gear tooth you just removed the case hardness their making it weaker. If the gear will run under light load you may get away with this , but if it will be under a high shock load from start up load. I'd think twice about it.​

9" Angle grinder​


My favorites:

Buy one.​
It’s called parts store​


This is why "I don't do the FaceBook."
 
Not a problem that it is close to the ways. There is space.
Since he is removing the outer diameter, his work holding is not bad.
If he was facing it might be dangerous, but I have faced without having the material against the face of the jaws.

I don't find it to be a dangerous or how not to moment.
 
Back
Top