First of all, that sure is some nice equipment you have there! What mill is that you own?
Not having ever used a rotary table before, I was thinking I would be using the chuck more in the vertical position( of the rotary table) and was thinking I really don't know what might come along so for $50 more it might be better to have the extra capacity.
I ran a CNC VMC for the last 25 years and on the last machine we had a fixture plate installed over the T slot table. 3/4" threaded holes alternating with 3/4" hardened bushings for pin placement (1200 holes?) and 1-2 8" Kurt vises as required. For drilling rings up to 30" we would bump it up against 2 pins sitting on strategically placed risers and clamp as needed. For cylinders up to 10" we clamped them in the vise with V block jaws fastened. We could have used a chuck but we had other machines to handle that but we could have sure used one at times!
I guess I have that large part mentality ingrained in my head from all those years and 1,000's of parts. I still haven't seen my mill ,PM940, so the size difference may open my eyes and make things much more clear as to the size of parts I can tackle. I think a 6" chuck might be best as I may hardly use it. Like I said I just lack knowledge about this home equipment stuff. Certainly a new journey for me and looking forward to it!