- Joined
- Mar 26, 2018
- Messages
- 8,666
+1Wow! That is one boadacious shaper! Many thanks, again, for all your work on this.
+1Wow! That is one boadacious shaper! Many thanks, again, for all your work on this.
As long as the cutting tool is ground properly, I wouldn't expect the load to be that high on the return stroke, or even on the forward stroke, for that matter. Of course, it rather depends upon the material, the width of the broach, and the DOC. For my project, the material is Aluminum and the maximum slot width is 6mm. 'Not a lot of force there, even with a moderately hefty DOC. Cutting something like a 12mm slot in stainless steel would be much more of a challenge.The problem is that with the overhung tool extending so far out from the hinge of the clapper is that the tool dragging in the cut on the return stroke tends to want to lift and try to jam up even more, begging to break something. I am a bit skeptical that the collet will be able to keep the bar tight without slipping axially. There is another type of bar that mounts directly in place of the tool post hele in place with a nut on the outside.
That's not a bad idea, in any event. My previous post notwithstanding, a shaper is a pretty brutal piece of machinery, as I am sure you are well aware. It puts some serious stress on... well pretty much everything.I'm a little concerned about the collet/bar spinning as well, though the Fireball Tools guy made this and seemed happy with it. I figure worst case, I can pin the bar in place or something.