The biggest problem with the 109 is not the spindle, it is the speed. It is just not slow enough. If you have just a plain pulley in the headstock you need to get the "planetary" backgear set with a 3 step pulley. Like this one:
This will reduce the spindle speed to 1/5 of the speed when engaged. It is a must on the 109. My
109.0703 109.0702 didn't have one
(although it came with one from the factory when it was made in 1941) when I got it. I bought the best one I could find off of eBay (I am in the process of replacing the bearings in the backgear - they have a reputation for being noisy).
You can see one being pulled apart at 9:42 in this video:
With a regular pulley & motor, the 109 can have speeds of 580 to 2040 RPM which is way to fast to cut gears or work with steel. Even with the planetary backgear unit, with a 1750 RPM motor your lowest speed will be around 116 rpm. Better, but it needs to be down in the 55 RPM range to be truly useful.
To control the speed of a 109, options are:
1) DC motors with VFD, or
2) Countershaft setup, or
3) a slower AC motor of say 900 RPM and forgo high speeds altogether.
I've decided on building a countershaft, option 2.
I found an esoteric mention of a Craftsman countershaft for the 109 on the British website
www.lathe.co.UK. It reads:
"...Obviously aware of the limitations imposed by this arrangement, the Company (Craftsman) offered later versions with the option of a double-step pulley on the motor and
a proper countershaft assembly, thus doubling the number of speeds and giving, according to the handbook, a range from 55 to 465 rpm in backgear and from 380 to 3050 in direct drive - a very much more satisfactory arrangement."
History and development of the Craftsman, Dunlap, Companion, Metalcraft, Metalmaster, AA109, 109, Simpson and Courlan and manufactured by the American
www.lathes.co.uk
This is the only reference that I have been able to find about the existence of a factory countershaft setup for the 109. I'd just like to see a photo of it so I could start making one. Perhaps they are wrong but I hope not.
Bent shafts on the 109 are due to worn bearings, too fast speeds and improper tool alignment (operator error).
For $120 You can get a new replacement spindle made from 4140 steel that is far stronger that the original ones made 70 years ago. I bought one and opted for the original 1/2" x 20 TPI thread but they are available with a 3/4" x 16 TPI. Look on eBay.
My need for a lathe is to make 7/8" x 2" round parts out of aluminum which the 109 can do very well.