You measured the spindle nose thread major diameter, not the register diameter. The actual thread diameter isn't particularly critical. Your first photo appears to be made up from three photos. What you need to measure is the unthreaded area to the left of the threads as shown in the lower right corner of your first photo. And the inside diameter of the unthreaded area before the threads start as shown in the lower left corner if the first photo. As I wrote earlier, the register diameter should be 1.5000"/1.4995".