I just loved reading this. It's hard to explain where good enough lies in the field of OK and scrap pile makings. Horribly the margins of error go out of bounds quickly when the tools used to "readjust" as it were from micrometers to "what size sledge hammer do I need?" levels At which point the fire extinguishers should quickly be located with haste.As an engineer managing other engineers, one of my greatest challenges was getting them to accept good enough. Best is the enemy of good enough, I would tell them. That doesn't mean that shoddy is good enough; it's very important to correctly identify how good something needs to be, including a margin to account for variables, and the means to rectify issues when the inevitable mistake happens that drives quality too low.
Steve Shannon, P.E.
I've been thinking about this for a while now. While my dad was one from that old mind-set of "never force it son, just get a bigger hammer", he also never did a job half way and those things that required precision received precision and accuracy. He had a great perspective of what was "good enough", but somehow I never seemed to be able to capture that and I always seem to have to have "perfection" and can't seem to realize that value of "good enough". I recently had quite a discussion with a special education councillor that comes to our school about that very thing and she was explaining things I could do to help me overcome my OCD when doing those things that don't require that kind of level of perfection. Things like purposefully doing some non-critical projects to a "good enough" level and leaving it that way........It hasn't worked. I tried to explain to her that I have actually done that a couple of times and while nobody else would probably ever notice the flaws in my workmanship I feel the need to point out and then apologize to anyone and everyone for my mucked up project. I eventually redid those projects to my level of "good enough". My wife just shakes her head at me. In a work or job environment I might be able to maintain that kind of acceptance when I come to understand what the level of perfection required is and then I could be satisfied with a job completed. But as I do this as a hobby, my attitude is "I'll do it the way I want to have it done." The best part of this whole mindset of mine is I find that reaching for higher levels quite often requires new tools!!I just loved reading this. It's hard to explain where good enough lies in the field of OK and scrap pile makings. Horribly the margins of error go out of bounds quickly when the tools used to "readjust" as it were from micrometers to "what size sledge hammer do I need?" levels At which point the fire extinguishers should quickly be located with haste.
Paul