When rotors are "dead flat", such as surface plate flat, the pads don't get pushed clear when the brakes are released. I have never had to replace them because of marks, letting the pads work into the grooves, after which everything was fine. In addition to automotive application, I have had several motorcycles with disk brakes. And brakes on a motorcycle are a couple orders of magnatude more critical than automobiles. Never put me on the pavement, I'd say they work fine.
That said, I make scale flanged wheels for 1-1/2 inch:1 ft (1/8) scale trains from them. I actually build 1/5 scale models, where the 7-1/2 inch track represents 36 inches.
Mounting up the car disk in a lathe, I cut off the actual disk, keeping the hub and a half inch of the "web". They finish out to very nice with a 3/16 flange. Hubs are made from several layers of 3/4 plywood, well sealed. My source was a "jack-leg" mechanic working at a small shop. The biggest problem I had was getting two the same diameter on an axle. I've still got a dozen or so single wheels, all different sizes. Even after trimming, there'ws too much difference to use together.
That was the reason I had to commission the Craftsman 12X36. Everything else was done on a 9X19, and fits. I had the 12X36 on hand because I liked the idea of the full "Norton" threading box and wanted to copy it. Other than that, after I built back gears and a reversing lead screw for the Grizz, the full "Norton" and the swing were the only factors. Well, and finding room for the four foot plus bed VS a little under 3 feet for the 9X19.
So why don't I have more trains? Seems my "git up and go" got up and left town after my last stroke (#6) left me in a wheelchair. I still have a few projects sitting out and getting rusty. Drives me nuts that all I have left is the small models and had to dispose of my motorcycles. I miss the wind in my face.
.