Thanks, I tried doing that, but the blade is too small for it. I'll have to buy a new one.
Get a 1/2" tall blade. They are so cheap that it usually costs more in shipping than the blade does. Use the right tool for the job.
What do you guys think of end mills with replaceable bits? I'm thinking of getting one and just getting carbide inserts. it may be cheaper this way?
Those are indexable carbide holders. Cheap carbide inserts are OK, but good ones get expensive quick. I don't own any milling cutters that use them, but do have some for my lathe. I usually use HSS if that tells you anything.
Just broke a 3/8" end mill trying to take off .005 off a mild steel square stock.
If you broke a 3/8 end mill on a .005 cut in mild steel you had speed or feed way too high, or didn't use cutting oil. Or it's not really mild steel. I have an el cheapo HSS 3/8" end mill I have used with much deeper cuts on mild steel and it's fine. Fix that first, then think about carbide. Carbide is more expensive and breaks or chips easier than HSS. If you are breaking HSS, you will absolutely break carbide. I usually run at about 1000 RPM and feed pretty slow. I'm on a bridgeport, so you might have to adjust.
You're learning, so am I. I suggest starting with HSS end mills and 6061 aluminum for some test cuts to learn feeds, speeds, and technique. It's a far more forgiving setup than what you have tried so far. Once you have that working well, then try known mild steel like 1018. Not mystery metal and certainly not tool steel. For the aluminum, I find a bit of WD40 helps prevent chip welding. No, it's not a cutting fluid, but it does help on aluminum. For steel you need something better, there are lots of choices. That reminds me, I need to get my mister set up on the mill...