I have to confess that when it comes to small idler wheels for things like this I've repurposed caster wheels normally used on the bottoms of machines. Get one with a reasonably flat profile (slight curve will center the belt (chuck it up in the 4-jaw and clock it concentric. Then bore to fit a bearing and press/Loctite it in on-centre.
Cheap and cheerrful, and a good way to reuse the odd caster you might have picked up in a box lot at a boot sale, or even new thewy're inexpensive compared to buying new lengths of large-diameter plastic.