Actually,W1 plain carbon steel will take a keener edge than any other steel. If you want to make a straight razor,use W1. W1 is getting harder to get as everyone is making more alloyed tool steels. MSC has W1 in their catalog in a few sizes. Or,you could buy water hardening round drill rod and forge it down flat.
The thing about W1 is,it will get sharper,but will not hold the edge as long as the more alloyed steels. It is also the most treacherous of all steels to quench. It will warp or crack more than other steels due to the sudden shock of the water quench.
For the best quench,dissolve ice cream salt in water until a potato will float in it. A brine quench keeps little air bubbles from forming on the surface of the steel you're quenching,giving a more even quench. The brine quench will soon rust your work and your tongs,so rinse them off quickly after quenching. Draw a straight razor to only a very light brown temper.
An OLD,USA made file would make good steel for a razor. It has about 1.25% carbon,which is what you need.
The thing about W1 is,it will get sharper,but will not hold the edge as long as the more alloyed steels. It is also the most treacherous of all steels to quench. It will warp or crack more than other steels due to the sudden shock of the water quench.
For the best quench,dissolve ice cream salt in water until a potato will float in it. A brine quench keeps little air bubbles from forming on the surface of the steel you're quenching,giving a more even quench. The brine quench will soon rust your work and your tongs,so rinse them off quickly after quenching. Draw a straight razor to only a very light brown temper.
An OLD,USA made file would make good steel for a razor. It has about 1.25% carbon,which is what you need.