I was in the same boat with the pulley. I went to a Tractor Supply and picked up a 3 1/2” pulley, which is the middle of the three step OEM pulley. I considered boring the three step pulley but then I would need to address the key way also, not having a broach, I settled for a new $8 pulley. With the VFD there is variable speed so it was a no brainer.