- Joined
- Jan 20, 2016
- Messages
- 1,011
I just re-read the specs on my 3M SpeedGlas 9100 helmet (around $350) and specs for HF #61610 Auto Darkening Helmet (around $45).
The SpeedGlass manual says "The welding filters keep the welder protected from UV and IR radiation. This protection remains always, in on, off, dark and light states. The curve also shows that the transmission in the light state is dominated by green light. Which is the reason for the green glass in the welding filter." This was explained to me by the dealer that even if the auto darkening didn't work (the lens was at the lightest or "resting/off") full UV and IR protection would be afforded.
The specs for the HF states "UV/IR protection up to DIN 16 at all times". I take that statement to mean that it has similar UV/IR protection (even when off) as the SpeedGlass helmet. I don't know that for sure though.
I have an older HF auto darkening helmet and have struck arcs with both helmets when they were in the "off" or lightest settings. I have not experience flash burns with either helmet (although I have gotten flash burns when the helmet is laying on the bench beside me!).
My eyes might be less sensitive to burns though? (I had a mechanic working for me whom I would catch welding without a helmet - for minutes at a time. He never complained of burn symptoms. I had to threaten to fire him to keep him from welding without protection).
Comparing the SpeedGlass to the HF; The SpeedGlass is very much more adjustable - which is why I got it, for low amperage tig welding that the HF was not sensitive enough for. The SpeedGlass is bunches more comfortable - lighter, better head band, etc. but functionally, for most welding, they seem to do the same job and offer similar protection. Note: those are just my personal observations.
Maybe some food for thought?
The SpeedGlass manual says "The welding filters keep the welder protected from UV and IR radiation. This protection remains always, in on, off, dark and light states. The curve also shows that the transmission in the light state is dominated by green light. Which is the reason for the green glass in the welding filter." This was explained to me by the dealer that even if the auto darkening didn't work (the lens was at the lightest or "resting/off") full UV and IR protection would be afforded.
The specs for the HF states "UV/IR protection up to DIN 16 at all times". I take that statement to mean that it has similar UV/IR protection (even when off) as the SpeedGlass helmet. I don't know that for sure though.
I have an older HF auto darkening helmet and have struck arcs with both helmets when they were in the "off" or lightest settings. I have not experience flash burns with either helmet (although I have gotten flash burns when the helmet is laying on the bench beside me!).
My eyes might be less sensitive to burns though? (I had a mechanic working for me whom I would catch welding without a helmet - for minutes at a time. He never complained of burn symptoms. I had to threaten to fire him to keep him from welding without protection).
Comparing the SpeedGlass to the HF; The SpeedGlass is very much more adjustable - which is why I got it, for low amperage tig welding that the HF was not sensitive enough for. The SpeedGlass is bunches more comfortable - lighter, better head band, etc. but functionally, for most welding, they seem to do the same job and offer similar protection. Note: those are just my personal observations.
Maybe some food for thought?