That's going to be an awesome anvil, Peter.
Here's what I did today. These are chin rests for a rig that holds people's heads in position for photographing their hair diseases.
They are made of 3/4" Delrin.
I made the dished cut with a modified 3/8" carbide cove router bit. I had to mill off the bearing stud in the middle. I then chucked it in my mill and made the passes .26" both directions from the center.
Then I used my new facing mill to mill off the planer chatter marks on the faces of them and gang clamped them on edge in the mill vise to clean the saw blade marks off the edges and bring them to exact matching size. Dimensions were not critical, they just needed to be the same.
I used my router table and a 1/2" round-over to round the ends, then a 1/8" round-over to soften the top edges.
I was duplicating a Canfield part with some freedom of design. The Canfield chin rests also had the swirl marks at the bottom of the cut, so I'm ok with 'em. Besides, I couldn't figure how to remove them. Sanding Delrin does not produce very slick results, and they need to be slick for hygenic reasons.