Well did a second try on a piece of flat plate, dId not work this time. Plate was clean, and everything. The only problem was I ran out of propane and had to go get more, So it stopped boiling in the middle of the process, but did not make blue it at all. So I tried to do the bluing like was in the video that was posted, Heat and old oil, But I could never get an even look to it, Boy did it stink, Used oil burning in the open like that. Did find one thing, do not put the old oil in something that can melt. The heat of the metal heated up the oil, and even got so hot the oil pan flash fired. I do not like that type of Blackening at least not on a large piece. Just have to figure out why the hot mixture did not work.