Tailstock center setup question

dml66

H-M Supporter - Gold Member
H-M Supporter Gold Member
Joined
May 13, 2022
Messages
188
I'll be turning a piece of low carbon steel rod, nominal 7mm (0.2756") diameter, 0.003" per foot straightness tolerance. The stick out from the ER25 lathe chuck will be 2-7/8" which includes enough to part off the finished piece. Even though material removal is minimal, 0.003" off the diameter, I'm pretty sure I'll need to employ a tailstock live or dead center. I have very little experience with live or dead centers even though I own both ;).

I know I'll need to spot drill the rod to accommodate the center, should I do that with the rod stick out set to 2-7/8", or chuck it very close, spot drill, then re-chuck to 2-7/8"?

And, live or dead center?

Thank you.
 
Chuck up the stock as close as possible, then centre drill.

If you have a travelling steady, that would help if you wanted to do the full length turning of the stock in one run by helping to avoid the stock deflecting, even under a light cut.

Live or dead centre? Live centre.

Only times I have, personally, ever used a "dead" centre is either in the spindle when turning between centres with a live tailstock centre or with a dead centre in spindle and tailstock when setting alignment between headstock and tailstock.
 
Last edited:
It depends on how good your live center is. They've got bearings in them so there has to be a certain amount of clearance a.k.a. "slop" in there so it's free to turn. A design that uses groove-type thrust bearings, in addition to standard bearings, would work better in terms of its TIR.

If you're after .003"/ft that's a bit under .0008" over ~3 inches. Is your live center good enough for that requirement?
 
It depends on how good your live center is. They've got bearings in them so there has to be a certain amount of clearance a.k.a. "slop" in there so it's free to turn. A design that uses groove-type thrust bearings, in addition to standard bearings, would work better in terms of its TIR.

If you're after .003"/ft that's a bit under .0008" over ~3 inches. Is your live center good enough for that requirement?
The 0.003" per ft is the stated straightness tolerance of the material I'll be starting with, I imagine the piece I have could be dead straight. I see your point regarding the live center runout.
 
Last edited:
I'll be turning a piece of low carbon steel rod, nominal 7mm (0.2756") diameter, 0.003" per foot straightness tolerance. The stick out from the ER25 lathe chuck will be 2-7/8" which includes enough to part off the finished piece. Even though material removal is minimal, 0.003" off the diameter, I'm pretty sure I'll need to employ a tailstock live or dead center. I have very little experience with live or dead centers even though I own both ;).

I know I'll need to spot drill the rod to accommodate the center, should I do that with the rod stick out set to 2-7/8", or chuck it very close, spot drill, then re-chuck to 2-7/8"?

And, live or dead center?

Thank you.

My first thought, reading this post, is that if you're asking these questions, you NEED some additional test material, as you're gonna scrap some parts Cutting these test parts will be necessary. It would be easier to work down if you were cutting these out of 5/16 or 3/8 rod, where you had some room to take multiple cuts. To hit these with that small of a cut, first, you're going to validate and quantify the lathe setup, the tool setup, the cutting tool it's self, and generally EVERYTHING. Then you'll start making "real" parts. Some of that can be whittled down in time, as you get to know that lathe, but the only way to know how the lathe acts in a given operation is experience and repetition. Taking three thousandths off of the diameter of something is not trivial, as it means you've got one shot at a cut that's one and a half thousandths deep. This eliminates most of the practical ways to "land on a dimension", as the first time you "touch off" on the work, you might well already be over your depth of cut. You've got to nail it on the first go.

This test piece includes testing your centers. If you've got a live center (with bearings), it WILL have some quantifiable runout. If it's low enough to hit your tolerance, great. They're fast, simple, and easy. If that live center runs out too much, that's when the dead center (non-rotating) comes in. Because they don't turn, they have ZERO runout. But they themselves have a learning curve. You've got to have a good high pressure center lube, you've got to get it just tight enough, otherwise it's not doing it's job, but NOT too tight, because it'll overheat and burn up in no time...

Drill the center with the piece pretty much fully inside of the collet. Then for the cut, bring it out to dimension plus room to work, as you said. Find "zero", dial in the tool to the necessary cut, WRITE DOWN your two dial readings (cross slide and compound), and cut a piece. (Don't adjust the dials, you'll loose more accuracy than what you're trying to attain, save that for production work. Use the numbers that are there). Measure the diameter at each end. Does the difference between the two ends meet tolerance? (That is the DIFFERENCE, the taper TOLERANCE Don't bugger with diameter yet, as adjusting taper WILL affect the diameter as well... Only taper at first.). If it is in tolerance, then you're good. If no, then on something that small, you're "probably" looking at simply shifting the tailstock to match the job, even if it gets shifted back where it was after to match your "normal" work. Make the correction, then cut another one. Once that's dialed in over the required length, do the same, except check the ends AND the middle of the part. You might be OK with that, but if your tool is not cutting freely at that small depth of cut, you might also find a "belly" in the part, where the center portion is fatter than either of the two iends. IF there's a belly, that WILL be part deflection, and is going to require a more freely cutting tool bit (or a follow rest) to correct. And honestly, it sounds like it might be getting a little crowed in there for a follow rest on such a small part.

Then, and ONLY then, consider the diameter. (DO NOT change multiple variables at one time, unless they're WAY off the map.... You'll chase the lathe in circles all around the shop.). So, once that little part is cutting straight (within tolerance of straight), THEN, look at the diameter. Take your written numbers, and dial in or out from where you were, and cut a diameter. Measure that diameter, move in or out from there until you can NAIL your final part in one pass. Pay attention to the dials. Make sure the compound is where it's supposed to be (perhaps "preset" that so it's dead nutz on a number so that you can see that it has not been disturbed). On the cross slide, pay CLOSE attention. One thousandth per graduation is probably a coarse resolution, you're more'n likely going to be splitting marks at least in half, if not quarters to hit the sweet spot.

IT sounds like a bunch, but really, after the first time or two, it goes pretty quick. Just work systematically through it.

Pro tip- If you're doing "test parts" to validate a setup, keep a sharpie or paint pen nearby. You MAY get your useful parts out of the test material, but every one that falls outside of dimension will be visually indistinguishable from those that do fall in spec. MARK the out of spec ones clearly. There's nothing quite like handing somebody a bad part, while the good one is sitting right on the workbench....
 
Minor terminology point, but you are going to be center drilling, not spot drilling the part. Spot drills are most commonly 118* or 135* to match the two most common twist drill point angles. You want to use a center drill which has a 60* cutting angle to match your centers. I suspect this comes up because so many folks talk about "spot drilling" when they're actually using a center drill...they're still spotting holes so it mixes up the terminology.

BTW, actual spot drills are one of the best additions to my shop in the past few years...way better than a center drill for spotting holes you intend to use a twist drill on. I've found you have to be a touch careful getting started if you're using a 118* spotting drill with a 135* twist drill, and vise versa, just easy pressure until the angles even out and it works just fine.

For your project something not mentioned is that you need to know that your tailstock is absolutely centered of you'll wind up with taper in the part. Just using the alignment marks on the tailstock isn't close enough. You either need to do a two collar test bar or bite the bullet and buy a tailstock alignment tool. I got tired of doing the two collar test bar drill, bought the tailstock alignment tool and it has saved me a LOT of time....worth every penny (not too expensive at $65 pretty much anywhere you can find them).

 
Last edited:
Great recommendations, suggestions and corrections, thank you!

I agree the stock may have insufficient diameter to make suitable turning cuts, I do have a piece of 5/16" 12L14 in the bin I may use to practice on while I wait for some larger diameter stock.
 
This TS Alignment Gage came to my attention some time ago, I discounted it back then because the lathe bed was 10" at the time, there was no room to fit a 12" bar. Now that the bed is 16", it sure looks as if this gage will work, and it's affordable enough to escape the eagle eyes of my finance chairperson :) .

I must admit to having the Edge Tech bar on my "purchase list". Would have purchased one this week, but missus decided, rightly so, to pay a bill with the money I had saved for it! Meh, she did discuss with with me and we agreed to "offset" me ordering the bar by two weeks, whereby she will pay for it direct from her income as re[payment, so no major loss.
 
This TS Alignment Gage came to my attention some time ago, I discounted it back then because the lathe bed was 10" at the time, there was no room to fit a 12" bar. Now that the bed is 16", it sure looks as if this gage will work, and it's affordable enough to escape the eagle eyes of my finance chairperson :) .

Personal opinion-
If you make your own test bar it's a lot more likely that it's scaled to the size of your lathe, and the act of making this will be an excercise in working with errors that ALL lathes have (NO exceptions). The ONLY DIFFERENCE between the most rusted, bent, twisted, and destroyed old manual lathe, and modern CNC microinch capable lathes is how many decimal points you can reasonably take it to.

Make a dead center, right in a worn out chuck if you don't wanna bother be fancy. Use a dead center, or a live center with a good enough tolerance (verified tolerance, not published) for the work you do. Turn the bar between centers. Any material you want, so long as you can get a half decent finish. Rough in the shape, take ONE cut on one ring, DON'T TOUCH THE DIALS, stop the lathe, move the carriage back, put the part back in end for end, and cut the second ring.

The real trick and the real value in making your own, is WHILE YOU'RE DOING IT, think through, study, question, and observe what's happening, and why the fact that your (presumably) inadequate taper turning machine with no accuracy and no alignment, and not even a good way to measure it has just made you a "perfect" part*

* Perfect does not exist. Perfect is simply a word that means you've exceeded your ability to measure further.

Or buy one, I'm not judging. I'm just saying that while the bought one is "quicker" and it's already done, (and not "unreasonably" priced), I think there's a lot more value in making your own that just the bar it's self.
 
Back
Top