It is thought by many (including my machinist mentor) that many - most? - of the popular makers of lathes, SB. Logan, Sheldon, etc, used a metal similar to todays 12L14, which is an easily workable metal and can be readily substituted with most anything in the scrap box. Couple years ago I needed a complete set of change gears for a Emco Compact 10 - 10 gears - and used what was in my scrap box (and my mentors, that was a lot of scrounging!) 4 of them were assorted cast iron and the rest was "scrap yardominium". So if you, or your buddies, have a good selection in your scrap box, jump in and start making gears with what ever you can find.